Dominik Mysterio was warned not to mess with his family during his match at WrestleMania 39. At the event, Dominik Mysterio did battle with his father, Rey Mysterio. The Mysterio family imploded in a match that had been building since he joined the Judgement Day at Clash at the Castle the year prior.

After he and Rhea Ripley invaded the house of his father Rey Mysterio in December 2022, Dominik Mysterio was "arrested" and subjected to "hard time" in prison. This prison stint later came full circle as Dominik entered the stage of WWE WrestleMania 39 via a police van while secured in handcuffs.